49 Comments
User's avatar
Francine's avatar

This is a great feature, definitely do more!

I've always considered myself a "good" shopper. Meaning, I generally buy within my means, shop sales, etc. But I have to tell you (and I'll let these other writers know too) that your substack (plus a few others, Harry Styles, Rabbit Fur Coat, Tiffanie Darke, 5 Things, etc) has complete changed the way I shop. I had 3 months of a no-buy (super easy for me in spring/summer bc who cares). Made a wish list of 5-10 new things for fall/winter and 100% stopped buying fast fashion or synthetic garments. When I shop, I shop eBay, TRR or thrift shops. "New" suede jacket? eBay! "New" Prada sweaters? TRR! Anyhow, I just want to let you know that you've made a difference!

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

this made my day...im so happy

Expand full comment
Ingrid Haring-Mendes's avatar

I have a black Club Monaco dress that I bought in 1996! and I still wear it!

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

ok I love that! I was born in 1996 AND worked at Club Monaco in college <3

Expand full comment
Ingrid Haring-Mendes's avatar

Haha love that I bought it the year you were born. And love Club Monaco's style. I wonder if their clothes would last as long today.

Expand full comment
Hey Mrs. Solomon on Style's avatar

LOVED! If you do it again, I volunteer! Granted I will have to check receipts bc menopause has robbed me of my ability to recall whether something is 5 years old but I WILL DO IT! What a delight. XOXOXO

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

adding you to my list ❤️

Expand full comment
Hey Mrs. Solomon on Style's avatar

xoxoxox woo hoooo ;-)

Expand full comment
Vicki A. Sanford's avatar

I love everything!!! I volunteered at St. Vincent De Paul thrift store in Lake Havasu City, AZ. for several years and got a beautiful Coach purse for $5

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

Very lucky

Expand full comment
The Style Investigator's avatar

I feel like the key issue is not how much it cost, or how long you've had it, but how many times you've worn it and what the cost-per-wear is. I have some items that didn't cost very much and I've had them for years, but I hardly ever wear them, so the cost-per-wear is high.

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

oh good point!

Expand full comment
Maria DeVoto's avatar

Love this!! Made me think about my own closet. My item is a sweater given to me secondhand from a friend in high school (10+ years ago) that I still wear all the time and always get compliments on!!

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

i love the items friends gave us in high school that are STILL WITH US

Expand full comment
Claire B's avatar

This is such a fun read!!

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

oh YAY! I hope it's helpful

Expand full comment
Kris Farren Moss's avatar

I have that exact green & blue L.L. Bean bag, minus the patch. It's been my favorite "bookbag" since elementary school, over 40 years ago.

Expand full comment
Anna Newton's avatar

An honour to be included! LOVED seeing what other people picked. Petition to make this a regular feature! X

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

Yay!!! Working on another one as we speak x

Expand full comment
Kate Hinsche's avatar

def do more of these! my mind immediately jumped to the dr martens i’ve had since i was 16 and my mom’s hand-me-down jean jacket. so fun

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

Yay more coming!!

Expand full comment
Aliza Sir's avatar

Can you do more of these??? Loved this!

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

yes yes if you'll add yours

Expand full comment
Aliza Sir's avatar

ooohh yes, i'll be thinking...

Expand full comment
Joanna Goddard's avatar

such a fun post!!

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

youre on my list for the next one but i wont be surprised if you submit your denim skirt AGAIN

Expand full comment
Aliza Sir's avatar

Yes yes more of these! (Just saw this after my comment below ☺️)

Expand full comment
debo's avatar

Great piece 💕

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

thank you x

Expand full comment
Paige Evers's avatar

This is a great insight into many different fashion treasures! I was an exchange student in Japan in 1987-88. My host Mom’s love language was buying me clothes. I still wear them today, from cardigan sweaters with ribbon details on the pockets to leather ankle boots. Those Japanese clothes, she’s, and purses are the highest quality of anything I’ve owned—37 years and still going strong! 😍

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

that's so sweet

Expand full comment
Paige Evers's avatar

Sorry, typo there, I meant clothes, shoes, and purses.

Expand full comment
Casey Lewis's avatar

delighted to be included in this! I've made it this long without a Uniqlo Heat Tech turtleneck but Anna Newton just singlehandedly convinced me I need one...

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

your winter self thanks you

Expand full comment
beaupre's avatar

I have a 20+ year old ralph lauren pink and white striped oxford (maybe even from the RL outlet?). It's perfect, I even brought it to Vientam to get copies made.

Expand full comment
Erika Veurink's avatar

getting copies made is the ultimate sign it's a perfect shirt

Expand full comment